Free MLB Baseball Picks

View free MLB picks and predictions released daily from our baseball betting experts during the 2026 season below.

Sort by sport:

Monday, September 21, 2026

Joe Duffy

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 6:40 PM in 3h
MLB | Nationals vs Tigers
Play on: Nationals +118 at Buckeye
Game Analysis

This is the strongest Luck Gap on today’s three-game board. Washington’s Luck Rating is +2.17 compared with Detroit at -10.57, producing a substantial 12.74 gap toward Washington. At this stage of a 162-game season, that is a legitimately meaningful regression differential.

One of our active league-wide systems also points toward Washington: road teams at least as strong as their opponent by winning percentage, facing an opponent coming directly off a road game, have gone 866-666, 56.5%, while generating $10,599 in historical profit. Detroit just completed a road series in Chicago before returning home.

The price adds appeal because Washington and Detroit enter with identical 73-83 records, yet the Nationals are getting substantial plus money.

Washington has also been the superior offensive club by the matchup numbers, averaging 5.14 runs per game compared with Detroit’s 4.39. Detroit returns home after an 8-1 loss to the White Sox.

The pitching matchup carries uncertainty. Detroit is expected to use River Ryan, whose limited major-league sample was excellent — 1.33 ERA and 1.18 WHIP in his first four MLB starts — but he is returning from a lengthy injury interruption. That uncertainty makes taking the plus price preferable to laying a substantial number with Detroit.

Our official outlaw line was roughly Detroit -155. Current Detroit prices around -152 imply Washington near +128, so there has been no reason to chase the favorite.

FREE PICK: WASHINGTON as the pros moved the line outside of premium bet range.

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 10:11 am
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Brandon Lee

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 6:35 PM in 3h
MLB | Blue Jays vs Orioles
Play on: Orioles -106 at Buckeye
Game Analysis

Monday's Free MLB Pick

PLAY ON: Orioles -106 

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 09:20 am
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Ricky Tran

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 6:40 PM in 3h
MLB | Nationals vs Tigers
Play on: Nationals +1½ -160 at Buckeye
Game Analysis

Ricky's 1* play on WAS.

Key Angle: It's important to remember that Ricky never makes a bet on any game based on just one angle. In order to make the grade, all his premium picks must meet several important criteria. He doesn't share all his secrets within his analysis, instead he chooses to reveal only the angle that he feels is the most significant. Here in this game the recent history of these two teams is particularly significant.

- The Nationals are 6-4 in their last 10 games.

- The Tigers are 2-4 in their last 6 games.

- The Nationals are 7-3 ATS in their last 10 head to head meetings.

Verdict: The value is on the road Underdog.

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 05:34 am
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Steve Janus

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 6:40 PM in 3h
MLB | Nationals vs Tigers
Play on: Tigers -140 at Ace
Game Analysis

1* Free Sharp Play on Tigers -140

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 12:00 am
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Jack Jones

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 9:45 PM in 6h
MLB | Twins vs Giants
Play on: Twins -113 at betonline
Game Analysis

Jack's Free Pick Monday: Minnesota Twins -113

The Minnesota Twins are at least still showing up to close out the season.  They have a solid offense scoring 4.6 runs per game and have a big advantage at the plate over the San Francisco Giants.  They also have the advantage on the mound and should be bigger favorites as a result.

The Giants quit a long time ago.  They are 2-7 in their last nine games overall to fall to 64-92 on the season.  Their offense has been alarmingly bad scoring a total of 7 runs on 15 hits in their 3-game sweep at the hands of the Dodgers over the weekend.  They were outscored 21-7 in the series.  Their lineup is probably the worst in baseball in their current state after the Arraez trade and with Devers on IL.

Zebby Matthews is 3-2 with a 3.15 ERA in his last six starts for the Twins.  He has allowed just 12 earned runs in 34 1/3 innings with 30 K's during this stretch.  I fully expect him to shut down this weak San Francisco lineup tonight.

Blade Tidwell is 1-2 with a 5.01 ERA in his eight starts this season.  He has allowed 23 earned runs in 41 1/3 innings.  Tidwell has allowed 14 earned runs and 5 homers in 20 2/3 innings in his last four starts for a 6.10 ERA during this stretch.  Bet the Twins Monday.

No. 2 Ranked Overall Capper All-Time! Jack Jones has absolutely CRUSHED the books over the past 8-plus years! He is riding a 7177-6259 Run L3297 Days on all premium plays that has seen his $1,000/game players cash in $324,270! He was the No. 6 Ranked Overall Capper in 2022 as well as the No. 8 Ranked Overall Capper in 2023! He finished as the No. 2 Ranked Overall Capper in 2024 with his $1,000/game players up $187,280 since January 1st, 2022!

Jack Jones has SIX Top-10 MLB Finishes (#4 2024, #8 2023, #5 2019, #6 2014, #6 2010, #4 2009) to his credit! He finished as the No. 8 Ranked MLB Capper in 2023 with his $1,000/game players up $21,110 in 2023! He backed it up by finishing as the No. 4 Ranked MLB Capper in 2024 with $1,000/game players up $34,230!

Jack has delivered a HOT 45-22 Run L11 Days to add to his 600-491 Run on all premium plays since February 11th! That includes a 18-10 MLB Run over his last 28 releases! Jack adds to it with his 20* MLB Monday Total DOMINATOR for just $39.95! This is an easy over/under winner on the bases tonight folks!

GUARANTEED or Tuesday MLB is ON JACK!

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 01:55 pm
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Rob Vinciletti

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 9:45 PM in 6h
MLB | Twins vs Giants
Play on: Twins -112 at betonline
Game Analysis

MASSIVE MONDAY card with a 6* 2X PERFECT NFL Top play and a 5* MLB Totals System from an Undefeated Late season system. Comp play below.
 
The MLB Comp play for Monday is on the Minnesota Twins. Game 955 at 9:40 eastern. The Giants apply to this 1-17 system since 2004 that plays against them and Game 156 home Monday teams in the first game of the 2nd to last series of the season if they are not favored by -240 or more, have a .600 or less win percentage, the total is 7 or more, they have a lefty the game before and tonights opponent has a .390 or higher win percentage. This is the top level data we use for these late season games that separates us from many others. Tidwell goes for SF and they have lost 8 of his 10 starts and he has a 5.88 home ERA. Minnesota has Mathews going and he comes off a 6 innings 2 ht shut out performance against the Yankees and they have won 7 of his last 9 starts. SF has lost the last 6 after playing the Dodgers. Look for the Twins to take the opener. GL Rob V-
 
SU: 1-17-0
 
2005/09/26 box Mon 2005 home Phillies Brett Myers -R Mets Jae Seo -R -155 9 9 9-7 1-1 3-1 2 2 O -1 L 5-6
2006/09/25 box Mon 2006 home Phillies Randy Wolf -L Astros Chris Sampson -R -155 10.5 9 8-8 1-0 2-1 0 -1.5 U -1 L 4-5
2007/09/24 box Mon 2007 home Mets Mike Pelfrey -R Nationals Matt Chico -L -220 9.5 9 12-11 1-1 1-9 0 7.5 O -9 L 4-13
2007/09/24 box Mon 2007 home Tigers Nate Robertson -L Twins Carlos Silva -R -150 10 9 7-6 1-0 0-2 0 -8 U -2 L 0-2
2009/09/28 box Mon 2009 home Red Sox Michael Bowden -R Blue Jays Scott Richmond -R -200 9.0 7 7-14 0-0 0-8 6 7.0 O -6 L 5-11
2010/09/27 box Mon 2010 home Guardians Carlos Carrasco -R Tigers Armando Galarraga -R -136 8.5 9 8-13 1-0 3-2 0 0.5 O 3 W 6-3
2010/09/27 box Mon 2010 home Rays Wade Davis -R Orioles Brian Matusz -L -170 8.5 9 3-9 1-1 0-4 0 -4.5 U -4 L 0-4
2013/09/23 box Mon 2013 home Mariners Brandon Maurer -R Royals Yordano Ventura -R 124 7.5 12 6-11 2-2 1-2 0 3.5 O -1 L 5-6
2015/09/28 box Mon 2015 home Orioles Chris Tillman -R Blue Jays Marco Estrada -R -109 9.0 9 4-10 0-0 2-1 0 -2.0 U -1 L 3-4
2015/09/28 box Mon 2015 home Rangers Colby Lewis -R Tigers Justin Verlander -R -147 8.5 9 10-12 1-0 0-6 0 2.5 O -3 L 4-7
2017/09/25 box Mon 2017 home Athletics Daniel Gossett -R Mariners Felix Hernandez -R -105 9.5 9 4-7 0-0 0-7 0 -1.5 U -6 L 1-7
2017/09/25 box Mon 2017 home Phillies Aaron Nola -R Nationals AJ Cole -R -197 8.5 9 6-8 0-0 0-2 0 -4.5 U -2 L 1-3
2018/09/24 box Mon 2018 home Blue Jays Marco Estrada -R Astros Dallas Keuchel -L 163.0 9.0 9 11-11 0-1 0-4 1 -1.0 U -2 L 3-5
2018/09/24 box Mon 2018 home Cardinals Jack Flaherty -R Brewers Dan Jennings -L -142.0 8.0 9 8-9 1-0 1-2 0 2.0 O -2 L 4-6
2018/09/24 box Mon 2018 home Cubs Cole Hamels -L Pirates Jameson Taillon -R -159.0 8.0 9 7-7 1-0 0-4 2 -2.0 U -4 L 1-5
2018/09/24 box Mon 2018 home Diamondbacks Robbie Ray -L Dodgers Clayton Kershaw -L 176.0 7.5 9 7-9 0-0 1-3 2 3.5 O -3 L 4-7
2018/09/24 box Mon 2018 home Mariners James Paxton -L Athletics Daniel Mengden -R -160.0 7.5 9 6-10 0-0 1-4 1 2.5 O -4 L 3-7
2018/09/24 box Mon 2018 home Rays Diego Castillo -R Yankees Jonathan Holder -R 113.0 8.0 9 2-8 0-1 0-3 0 -3.0 U -3 L 1-4
 
2026/09/21 21:45 Mon 2026 home Giants Blade Tidwell -R Twins Zebby Matthews -R 100 8

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 12:38 pm
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Alex Smart

Game Details
Sep 21 '26, 6:35 PM in 3h
MLB | TOR vs BAL
Play on: UNDER 7½ -105
Game Analysis

Trends, Sharp Plays & Props for Monday, September 21, 2026
(Getaway-night hangover, three games, a 7.5 in Baltimore, and Oracle sitting at 8 like a September night is supposed to)

Sunday already paid a few of the clean ones. Monday shrinks to three. Night baseball. A 7.5 at Camden. An 8 at Comerica. An 8 at Oracle. Do not invent a 15-game card. The number is talking in two spots. The rest is filler.

League-Wide Vibes So Far (Late September 2026)
Home clubs still hanging around 54 percent. Favorites still cashing in the mid-50s. Scoring still lives in the 4.3–4.7 neighborhood unless Colorado is involved. Colorado is not involved. Monday slates get thin. Night games. A 7.5 in Baltimore. That is how the board gets honest.

Bet under 8 on Monday night slates with three games or fewer.
That spot since 2025: 11-6 (64.7%) with an average total of 7.8. (+4.2 unit$, ROI=22.4%)

Bet home clubs in September games posted 7.5 when both starters sit in the mid-3s to low-4s.
That spot since 2025: 14-9 (60.9%). (+3.8 unit$, ROI=15.1%)

The Games That Actually Matter

Toronto Blue Jays @ Baltimore Orioles (6:35 ET)
Trey Yesavage (5-5, 3.65) vs Shane Baz (6-15, 4.11). Blue Jays 77-79. Orioles 75-81. Total 7.5. Baltimore -110 to -112. This is the lowest clean number on the card. Camden in September with two righties is a grind, not a track meet. Do not get cute fading a pick’em because Yesavage has been off the board. The 7.5 is the ticket.

My Plays:
• UNDER 7.5
• Orioles ML
• Team Prop: Blue Jays Team Total Under 3.5
• Player Props: Baz Over 4.5 K

Bet under 7.5 in Orioles home games posted 7 to 7.5 in September.
The Under’s record since 2025: 9-4 (69.2%) with an average over/under of 7.4. (+4.4 unit$, ROI=30.8%)

Bet the home side in a September pick’em when both clubs sit under .500.
Two 75-win clubs. 7.5 total. Home gets the last at-bat. (+2.1 unit$, ROI=16.4%)

Washington Nationals @ Detroit Tigers (6:40 ET)
DJ Herz vs River Ryan. Nationals 73-83. Tigers 73-83. Total 8. Detroit -150 to -156. Two arms coming back onto the card. Comerica in September with an 8 is how 8 gets tested. The juice on Detroit is the tax for playing at home, not a lock.

My Plays:
• UNDER 8
• Tigers ML if you cannot live without a side
• Leave -1.5
• Player Props: Herz Over 4.5 K

Bet under 8 in Tigers home games in September when the total opens 8 to 8.5.
That spot since 2025: 8-5 (61.5%) with an average total of 8.1. (+2.4 unit$, ROI=16.8%)

Bet against laying -150 or more on a .500-ish club in a three-game Monday.
Same record. Same September. The number is fat for the spot. (+1.6 unit$, ROI=14.2%)

Minnesota Twins @ San Francisco Giants (9:45 ET)
Zebby Matthews (9-10, 4.74) vs Blade Tidwell. Twins 73-83. Giants 64-92. Total 8. Minnesota -118. Oracle at night with an 8 is the West Coast version of Baltimore. Minnesota is the better roster on paper. Better does not always mean 8–2 by the bay. If you play this game, take the 8 and leave the fancy run line.

My Plays:
• UNDER 8
• Twins ML
• Twins -1.5 only if you get plus juice
• Player Props: Matthews Over 5.5 K

Bet under 8 in Giants home night games posted 7.5 to 8.5.
Oracle, September, night. That is how 8 gets honest. Since 2025: 10-6 (62.5%) with an average total of 8.0. (+3.2 unit$, ROI=18.2%)

Bet Minnesota on the road when the total is 8 and the home club sits under 70 wins.
64-92 does not become a dog-killer because it is Monday. (+1.8 unit$, ROI=15.6%)

Quick Hits
• Monday night = lower-scoring lean. No Coors. No 11.
• Do not lay -156 on Detroit if you can live with the 8.
• A 7.5 in Baltimore is the cleanest total on the board.
• An 8 at Oracle is the quiet hammer of the late window.
• Plus money in San Francisco is the dog of the night if you need one.

Smart Money — Top 5 Recommended Bets Monday

Under 7.5, Blue Jays at Orioles — lowest total, September night.
Under 8, Twins at Giants — Oracle night, 8.
Orioles ML vs Toronto — pick’em, last at-bat.
Under 8, Nationals at Tigers — two rusty arms, Comerica.
Twins ML at San Francisco — better club, fair price.

Little Prop Parlay: Baz Over 4.5 K + Matthews Over 5.5 K + Herz Over 4.5 K.

September baseball is part pennant math, part hoping the bullpen you trusted does not spontaneously combust. Always check final pitchers. Things change fast. Shop the number.

Enjoy the games, bet the tickets that pay, and may that 7.5 in Baltimore hold up long enough to start the Monday card clean.

Pick Released on Sep 21 at 09:52 am
CLICK HERE FOR PREMIUM PICK OPTIONS

Get the best available baseball selections for Monday that SCI experts have to offer by checking out the expert MLB picks section.

Featured MLB Picks
Back to Top